Real news and fake news


Greetings Reader,

I recently heard former late night television star Stephen Colbert describe his erstwhile gig as the equivalent of “being lowered like carbon rods into a radioactive pool every day, and then being pulled out and put in front of a camera to radiate it back out at the audience at a non-lethal rad level.”

Sometimes I feel like I could say the same thing about my current gig.

On the one hand, I feel the need to know what’s going on in the world, both for myself and for the sake of being able to write about how the news looks from a yogic perspective.

On the other hand, staying on top of so much sickening news is . . . sickening.

The therapeutic dose of lithium used in the treatment of bipolar disorder is dangerously close to its toxic dose and has to be closely monitored.

Similarly, I try to monitor my news intake: enough to be well informed, not enough to trigger manic depression.

When accessed in therapeutic doses, the news can reveal reasons for hope (looks like things are going pretty well in Mamdanistan), causes for concern (record high diesel fuel prices that will have a domino effect this winter), and opportunities to do something (thank you to everyone who showed up at the Kenedy Center).

And we can’t just ignore the hyper-negative news — the damage that can’t be undone — because eventually, but inevitably, the opportunity to hold people accountable will come.

The news gets toxic when we overdose on that negativity and convince ourselves that there’s nothing we can do about it. Regulating our news intake so that it’s motivating rather than paralyzing is one way to keep it together.

But that only works if the news we’re getting is real, which makes being able to distinguish between real news and fake news all the more important.

In some respects, it’s getting easier to tell which news organizations are being truthful in their reporting: being banned from the White House is the new stamp of credibility.

In other respects, parties more invested in the pursuit of power than people’s prosperity are hellbent on sowing chaos and confusion through the use of AI generated phony baloney.

Yoga wisdom offers us some tools to help us tell the difference between real news and fake news, and it starts by pulling the curtain aside to take a good look at the messenger behind the message.

The metaphysics of yoga may seem abstract and theoretical at first glance, but they’re actually a practical set of tools for understanding human nature.

Case in point: how the Bhagavad Gita describes the characteristics of people who value truthfulness verses the characteristics of those whose very nature is to traffic in falsehoods:

“Nonviolence, truthfulness, freedom from anger, . . . having compassion for all beings, freedom from greed, gentleness, modesty, stability, . . . freedom from envy and the desire for honor . . . these are the characteristics of one who is endowed with a saintly nature.” — Bhagavad Gita 16.2-3

It’s a little like a “where there’s smoke, there’s fire” proposition: if someone is relatively free from anger, greed, and envy, there’s a relatively good chance that they’re going to be a reliable source of accurate information.

On the other hand,

“Duplicity, arrogance, conceit, anger, cruelty, and ignorance – these are the characteristics of one who is endowed with a demonic nature. People of an ungodly nature do not know what should be done nor what should not be done. Neither cleanliness nor proper behavior nor truth is to be found in them.” — Bhagavad Gita 16.4 and 7

Notice how dishonesty is both the first and last attribute of those who are egotistical, smug, resentful, mean, and witless? Show me a mean-spirited ego-maniac and I’ll show you a liar.

The temperament of a saintly person is sattvic, characterized by qualities associated with the material mode of luminance. A demonic mentality is characterized by rajasic and tamasic qualities; attributes of the material modes of passion and darkness.

This is a great example of how looking at the world through the lens of the three guṇas, the three qualities of material nature — sattva, rajas, and tamas (luminance, passion, and darkness) — can bring clarity in situations where bad actors are going to great lengths to make us believe things that aren’t true.

In yoga, our objective is to lift our consciousness out from under the influence of the lower modes of passion and darkness and situate ourselves in the mode of luminance in order to see the true nature of the self.

Similarly, when the news media is situated in the mode of luminance, we get the truth about what’s going on. When it’s situated in the modes of passion and darkness, you get news that’s unreliable at best, incorrect at worst, or, , purposely incorrect.

“Knowledge arises from luminance, greed arises from passion, and madness, delusion, and the disappearance of knowledge arise from darkness.” — Bhagavad Gita 14.17

The news may still feel toxic because so much of it is being generated by dumb and evil people doing dumb and evil things.

But if we at least have access to honest reporting about the dumb and evil things they’re doing and the tools of discernment that yoga offers to help us tell real news from fake news, then there’s a chance we can make it to the ballot box without setting off any Geiger counters.

Wishing you all good fortune,

- Hari-k

Hari-kirtana das

If you’re ready to apply yoga philosophy to your own life—or teach it with clarity and feeling—my classes and workshops create space to sharpen your thinking, steady your inner life, and connect your practice to what matters now.

Read more from Hari-kirtana das

Greetings Reader, After three weeks of practice, I feel confident in saying that I have mastered the art of being on vacation. Ate it up. Crushed it. Knocked it out of the park. Stuck the landing. It was great. I totally cleared my calendar of everything except all of my meetings and appointments to make sure I would have a few zeptoseconds every day to relax. And when I wasn’t busy relaxing, I renovated my entire website, planned out my workshop and course schedule for the next 12 months,...

Hi Reader, Sharing a bit of yoga philosophy before students start moving is a great way for a yoga teacher to open a class. It can also be challenging. But what’s even more challenging is weaving that bit of philosophy into your class while your students are moving. But that's how you turn the philosophy you talk about into the philosophy that everyone feels. We can tell students that Warrior Pose teaches us how to be strong, Tree Pose teaches us how to stay grounded, and Child’s Pose teaches...

Greetings Reader, A few weeks ago I spent the better part of an idyllic afternoon hanging out with a friend on a quiet veranda overlooking a stretch of woods behind my apartment complex. Our meeting was both pleasant and purposeful: our plan was to explore some ideas about how we could expand our support for the Free DC movement here in our besieged capital. But before we got down to the business of resistance, we took some time to catch up. I mentioned that my wife and I are planning a trip...